Top Pet-friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY

Enjoy unparalleled bayfront living in this pet-friendly apartment, offering direct access to Fire Island's town, dining, nightlife, and the ocean, with a private deck featuring a hot tub and loungers.
This dog-friendly three-bedroom apartment accommodates up to six guests and includes a kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, plus complimentary waterfront and beach gear like kayaks and paddle boards.

A private, sequestered studio in quiet Bayport offers a tranquil escape, conveniently located within 500 meters of Bayport's main street and parks, with easy ferry access to Fire Island beaches.
This pet-friendly studio boasts a comfortable queen bed, a large bathroom with a roomy shower, and includes amenities like Wifi and off-street parking, making it ideal for two guests seeking a dog-friendly seaside retreat.

Boasting secluded privacy on two old-growth lots, this Fire Island Pines house is just 150 steps from a beautiful white-sand beach, offering an authentic bohemian lifestyle.
This pet-friendly house features multi-level decks including a rooftop, a party-friendly outdoor space, and a unique artist's paradise ambiance, perfect for guests and their dogs.

Offering direct bayfront living with sweeping water views, this three-bedroom apartment in Sayville is just a short walk from town amenities and the ocean, making it an ideal pet-friendly base.
This 94 square meter apartment boasts a private bayfront deck with a hot tub and loungers, and includes kayaks and paddleboards for exploring the water, perfect for guests with pets seeking seaside adventures.