Pet-friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Located in the heart of Greenport Village, this pet-friendly apartment offers immediate walking access to all local restaurants, bars, and shops, and is just 528 feet from the beach.
This newly renovated two-bedroom apartment comfortably sleeps eight guests and features a full kitchen, air conditioning, and a garden, with the Shelter Island Ferry and Hampton Jitney just four blocks away for easy exploration.

Offering direct waterfront access, this pet-friendly apartment in East Marion features a private beach on Peconic Bay, located just miles from Greenport and Orient Point.
This dog-friendly accommodation provides ample space for up to 7 guests, with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, and includes a full kitchen, air conditioning, and garden access, making it ideal for families.

Enjoy tranquil pond views and deeded access to Menantic Creek for kayaking from this exceptional pet-friendly apartment, just a 5-minute stroll to the island boatyard marina and Salt restaurant.
This spacious 3-bedroom apartment on 1.12 acres offers a private screened porch, entertainment deck, organic garden, outdoor shower, and a swimming pool, perfect for a memorable stay with your dog-friendly family.

Enjoy direct waterfront access in Orient Village with this newly renovated, pet-friendly apartment offering spectacular sunrise and sunset views of Bug Lighthouse.
This apartment provides complimentary beach bicycles, kayaks, and stand-up paddleboards, and is just a short walk to Orient Village attractions like the Country Store and yacht club.