Shelter Island, NY Hotels: no available offers. Here are other great options for your stay!
Laid Back Relaxation
apartment, Shelter Island Heights
Just 500 feet from Crescent Beach and Sunset Beach, this newly updated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom apartment in Shelter Island Heights offers a truly pet-friendly escape with an outdoor shower and private wooded yard.
This dog-friendly ranch boasts an open living space with cathedral ceilings, a fireplace, and is within walking distance to Shelter Island Heights town and a golf course, comfortably accommodating up to 6 guests.
This dog-friendly ranch boasts an open living space with cathedral ceilings, a fireplace, and is within walking distance to Shelter Island Heights town and a golf course, comfortably accommodating up to 6 guests.
Harbor Heights
apartment, Greenport
Enjoy exclusive use of an outdoor jacuzzi and cabana at this pet-friendly apartment, located just three blocks from the beach in Greenport.
This newly renovated two-bedroom apartment is situated in Greenport, offering excellent walkability with the village and Shelter Island Ferry just one block away, and the beach three blocks away.
This newly renovated two-bedroom apartment is situated in Greenport, offering excellent walkability with the village and Shelter Island Ferry just one block away, and the beach three blocks away.